All about tuning cars

Independent assessment (examination) of damage from the gulf of the apartment. Forensic examination Independent examination of housing

Any citizen or organization can order a study privately. In this case, an independent appraisal examination is carried out on the basis of an agreement for the provision of the corresponding service.

If the need for such research has arisen in the framework of the criminal process, it is appointed by the order of the inquiry officer or investigator. The employees of the Federal Tax Service can engage specialists on a contractual basis to carry out an appraisal examination for the implementation of the tax control function. Within civil or arbitration process the study is ordered by a court ruling.

Despite the fact that the right to attract specialists in these cases is granted authorized bodies and officials, you can apply for research. To do this, it is necessary to compose in writing type document forensic examination and justification of its necessity.

They trust us:

Who can act as a forensic evaluator?

Forensic examination is primarily regulated by federal law"On state forensic expertise in Russian Federation", as well as other laws and acts regulating this or that activity, the area within which the forensic examination is carried out.

A forensic expert cannot be a person who is somehow interested in the outcome of the case. Therefore, the choice of an expert or expert organization is very important and can decide whether you win in court or not. As a rule, the party that requests the appointment of a forensic examination is obliged to provide the court with several commercial offers to conduct a forensic examination. The court appoints an expert at its own discretion, guided, in accordance with our practice, with the cost of services and the expert's experience.

When applying for a forensic examination, it is important to clearly formulate the questions, the answers to which will resolve the dispute. Since an incorrectly posed question to an expert will entail an unsatisfactory answer and delay trial You need to consult in detail with an experienced lawyer about the wording of the question.

How to choose the right forensic valuation expert

Despite the fact that there are a large number of certain specialists, their views on the same issue may differ due to their experience, specialization, and so on. Therefore, if you plan to apply for the appointment of a forensic examination, select such experts, whose competence the Court does not doubt.

  • First, it is necessary to provide documentary evidence of the right to conduct a particular activity, within the framework of which a forensic examination will be carried out. Moreover, very important role the experience of the expert plays, namely: see if there are any cases won in the courts, which were based on the conclusions of this expert.
  • Second, pay attention to the expert's specialization. Often a “narrow specialist” has a more objective view of the subject than a generalist.
  • Third, study the website of the company where the expert works. Often, even on the site, you can draw certain conclusions about the quality of the services provided by an expert company.

It happens that the results of the examination, due to the incompetence of the expert chosen by the court, do not satisfy any of the parties. In this case, it will be necessary to conduct a repeated appraisal examination, the payment of which will be entrusted to the party that will apply for it, or to both sides of the case.

For example, if you are interested in conducting a forensic appraisal examination, the result of which will be the conclusion of an expert appraiser on the market or other value of an object (real estate, easement, services, debt, etc.), you need to request from appraisal companies whose website inspires confidence, diploma of appraisal education of an expert, certificate of membership in SRO of appraisers, insurance policy professional activity appraiser, insurance policy of the company in which the expert works. If such a package cannot be provided to you, the specialist most likely does not have the right to conduct appraisal activities, which means that he cannot act as an expert in court.

In some cases, more than one forensic examination is required to resolve a dispute, since this dispute affects several areas of professional knowledge. For example, in order to establish an easement, it is necessary to conduct an examination, in which the expert will reflect the boundaries of the easement, and an examination, as a result of which a commensurate payment for this easement will be determined.

Therefore, when choosing an expert organization, it is important not to make a mistake, since this can turn the course of the case in one direction or another and determine the amount of your costs for the trial.

It is highly unlikely that this service will be suitable for a peaceful solution of the issue with neighbors or utilities. After all, the culprit of the gulf always thinks that he owes you a couple of thousand rubles. Anyone can make an estimate for repairs after the gulf on their own and voice the result to an opponent. Therefore, paying for some kind of simplified estimate is just a waste of money.

In the same case, if the guilty party says no, here an independent examination of the damage after the gulf is already needed in accordance with all the rules specified in the Law. Such a document is official and is needed to defend your position in court or before an insurance company.

Cost of damage assessment services

Damaged property

Why do you need a Bay Assessment

Flooding of an apartment is one of the situations that spoils relations between neighbors. In the overwhelming majority of cases, such controversial issues are resolved among themselves in a neighborly manner and do not imply taking the litter out of the hut. But this only applies to such a scenario in which the neighbor who flooded your home is a polite and adequate person.

There are frequent cases in which the culprit of the gulf not only does not apologize, but also, in addition, is rude to the injured party. And here, if your apartment flooded by neighbors from above who refuse to voluntarily compensate for the damage and even simply apologize for the inconvenience caused, the only way out of the situation is to go to court.

When writing a statement of claim, you will need to substantiate the amount of claims against a neighbor or a management company (if the bay happened due to its actions or inaction). This document is an independent assessment of the damage after the gulf of the apartment... The volume of the examination is about forty sheets. It includes a detailed analysis of the market in order to substantiate the application of market prices in the calculation to the court, and a construction estimate with the costs of materials, work, and other necessary points, and documents of the organization (giving the right to prepare an expert assessment for the court), photographs and much more.

The prices for the appraiser's work for the bay of apartments depend on the nature of the damage to housing or non-residential premises. After all, it happens that not only an apartment is flooded, but also non-residential premises(shop, office, warehouse, etc.).

STEPS

Step by step: what to do if neighbors flooded

When the apartment is flooded, the first thing to do is to shut off all the water supply vents to your own apartment. Indeed, in the confusion it is impossible to make out where it came from. It is likely that it is you who are flowing. Next, you should go up to the one who lives above you and check if it has flowed from him. In the event that it was not possible to eliminate the leak on its own. For example, an accident occurred due to the deterioration of engineering systems and the water supply pipe simply burst. Or the battery has flown off from overpressure.

An urgent need to inform the dispatcher of the utility service. After calling the SLM Management Company will take measures to eliminate the accident. The water supply to the house or entrance will be cut off, and repair and restoration work will be carried out. Employees of DEZ (homeowners' association, etc.) give themselves report about the consequences of the delay, therefore, they try to respond as quickly as possible to such requests from residents. Speaking in general about the assessment of the situation, they initially assume that the accident may also be their (DEZA) fault. So they worked more quickly - less will have to be reimbursed in court.

Request for an expert visit

In order to call an appraiser for the bay of an apartment, there is no need to first go to the office of the appraisal company. An application for appraisal of an apartment after the bay is made simply by phone or online. The date and the specific time, as well as the address of the object, are indicated in advance. Moments related to organizational issues, namely the conclusion of an agreement for the provision of services and payment with appropriate documentary evidence, occur directly at the object being evaluated. Independent expertise after the bay of the apartment has its own specifics, therefore prices for appraiser's services are announced at the stage phone call after clarifying the details of the damage caused. This is done in order to avoid unpleasant situations that sometimes everyone had to face: when there is one price on the site (or advertising), but in fact you have to pay more.

Bay apartment appraisal

This procedure includes the following steps:

  • Submitting an application by phone or online for an expert visit;
  • Inspection of damage by a specialist, drawing up an act, indicating measurements, specifics of damage and features of finishing the room, photographing all chips and leaks;
  • Conclusion of an agreement for the assessment of damage and payment for the services of an appraiser;
  • Preparation of an expert assessment, including a market analysis, an estimate for the repair of the premises, acts of inspection of an apartment after the bay, photographs of damage, documents of an appraiser and organization for the right to this activity;
  • Issuance to the customer of the final result of expert evaluation work in the office or delivery by courier.

Preparing for trial

Consider what documents are needed for the court. To file a claim for compensation for damage caused by the gulf of an apartment, in addition to an assessment, a number of documents will be required:

  • Statement of claim;
  • Assessment of damage from the gulf of the apartment;
  • Receipt of payment of the state duty for the consideration of the court case;
  • Document confirming the right to an apartment
  • Flooding Act (there are cases in which it is possible without it)

This is a list mandatory documents... The judge can sometimes require something in addition to it. Or, conversely, exclude something from this list. For example, if flooded due to the fault of the management company, and she does not issue an act, there is no reason not to accept the claim. After all, it is obvious that utilities are no longer outside observers, but an interested party in the case. Or if a claim is filed to protect consumer rights, then there is no need to pay state fee for the consideration of the case.

Topical issues

How will experts calculate the damage from the gulf?

An expert assessment for a court is fundamentally different from a conventional construction estimate. The evaluation album touches upon not only construction and technical issues, but also legal ones. The construction company's estimator prioritizes the benefit of the organization from the order, and the forensic expert - the validity of the document before the court.

When assessing the costs of restoring an apartment after the bay, the realities of the market are taken into account building materials and services, the need for preparatory work (carrying furniture, dismantling decorative elements, removing fungus, etc.), even the foreseen Administrative Code responsibility for the disposal of construction waste together with household waste. Therefore, garbage disposal is taken into account in the cost of repairs after flooding.

In addition to the economic and technical components of the expert assessment of damage, it is also taken into account legal issues... So the need to perform work and the consumption of materials must be confirmed by the provisions of SNiP. For the defendant in court will always prove to the last that he must compensate a couple of thousand rubles and no more. In contrast to this unchanged position, there is a reference to the requirements of the secondary legislation, which give independent evaluation legal force. This is especially true when the opposite side provides a simple construction estimate in its justification. An experienced lawyer can easily counteract this moment.

Is it possible to calculate the damage from the gulf according to state rates?

State penny prices (TEP, FER, etc.) are very attractive to those who want to minimize their costs to a neighbor to repair his home after flooding. Here an independent assessment takes into account an important point. According to already mentioned above building codes and rules, these indicators are used for the construction of very large objects (city, microdistrict, quarter), which participated in the tender and do the work for a pittance. None construction company for apartment renovations will not undertake to make repairs for such a price. And as mentioned above, the realities of the market must be taken into account when independently assessing the damage from the gulf of the apartment. For the court, real prices matter less than for the consumer of construction services.

Why do you need market analysis in expertise?

Showing the participants in the trial of the actual state of affairs in the repair services market is necessary for the defendant (neighbor, management company, fund overhaul etc.) did not appeal state prices for court session when considering a case for compensation for damage caused by the bay of an apartment.

What documents are needed for the assessment?

You should be aware that an independent examination of the assessment of damage has a huge difference from the assessment of real estate for a bank. To assess the bay of an apartment, the appraiser needs, first of all, the affected object itself (walls, ceilings, floors, furniture, etc.). For it is not the apartment that is evaluated as a separate object of law, but the interior decoration of this very apartment. Therefore, you should not be surprised when, having already faced the banking bureaucracy when applying for a mortgage, you suddenly hear that technical certificate BTI is optional.

Appointment by the Court of Additional Expertise

In the event that during the trial the court had significant questions that the original could not answer assessment of damage from the gulf of the apartment an additional examination can be appointed, that is, precisely by a court decision, with the issuance of an appropriate determination. The questions here may include not only the amount of damage, but also the cause of the damage, limitation period and many others. technical issues... The judge can either make a decision on the choice of a company for the construction and technical expertise, or ask for representatives of the parties to the dispute to choose similar organizations.

In this case, the appraisal company provides an information letter and a certificate of conformity. forensic expert, confirming his accounting specialty.

Does the appraiser need an act of the management company?

There are two separate points to distinguish. Utilities record the very fact of flooding the premises. That is, their document confirms the event: yes, the bay was then and there, and because of that. Moreover, in other articles, we considered situations when the DEZ does not draw up an act, and you can still file a lawsuit without such a document.

But the assessment of the damage after the gulf of the apartment itself answers the question of how much the damage costs and why. The principle of independence of this procedure implies that the appraiser may have a different vision of the situation than an employee of the management company. Sometimes the data of the examination and the act may differ. This is in the order of things, and they should not be identical. After all, the caretaker technician examines the apartment not as thoroughly as a representative of an expert institution.

Most importantly, neither the law nor the appraisal standards oblige the appraiser to base their opinion on a document from the utility and attach it to the appraisal report.

Assessment of moral damage

Based on the realities of our legislation and judicial practice, we can say that moral injury this is nothing more than a beautiful phrase from American cinema. Yes, the victim of the flooding, of course, experienced both anxiety and discomfort. And nerves and vanity took place. But the amount of moral damage in such situations is estimated at several thousand rubles. No more.

But! Since the dispute in court is precisely about material damage, then a kind of compensation for the experiences will be precisely cash payments, which is substantiated by the assessment of damage from the gulf of the apartment, prepared for the court. An independent examination involves a complete replacement of one or another coverage interior decoration even with minor damage. That is, when in practice it is possible to eliminate damage by performing the work locally. Thus, the saved funds will more than cover the moral damage.

How to assess the damage from flooding an apartment on your own?

If you have a lot of free time, this is not difficult to do. You can measure everything yourself with a tape measure, watch videos on YouTube, go to the construction market and ask the price for goods and services of local specialists. In doing so, you will receive very relative information about the price of apartment restoration. For in the process of repair it will definitely turn out that something has not been taken into account and will have to pay extra.

Moreover, an independent assessment of the damage is not suitable for the court. This will not be accepted as proof, since the principle of independence and objectivity is completely absent here.

What is the advantage of going to an appraiser? An independent examination after the gulf takes into account absolutely all the subtleties of the process (market, technical and legal), has legal force for filing a lawsuit, the cost of the assessment is recovered from the culprit.

The only plus of self-assessment of the cost of renovating an apartment is one. It's done for free.

Write a statement of claim

To go to court in order to compensate for damage, it is required to submit a number of documents, including a statement of claim. The claim must indicate who is the plaintiff, who is the defendant, as well as who is involved as a third party. It is necessary to describe the circumstances of the case and substantiate the claims, linking each moment to a specific article of each law. V statement of claim for the bay of an apartment, the amount of state duty is prescribed, which can be calculated based on an assessment of the damage.

In addition to the claim, there is a cost calculation. Where all are indicated legal costs subject to compensation. Namely, the costs of the state duty, the cost of the appraiser's services, moral damage, the services of a lawyer and others.

Download a sample statement of claim for compensation for damage caused by the gulf of the apartment, you can on the Internet or in the reference and legal system "Consultant Plus" or "Guarantor". And then fill it in yourself. It will be free. You can also contact lawyers who can draw up a claim much more competently and professionally, which will undoubtedly pay for itself in the process. After all, the judge, reading the statement, sees with whom he will initially have to deal.

How to write a pre-trial claim

Before you sue your neighbor for damages from the gulf, you must use all the "peaceful" means. You can just try to come to an agreement - most people are quite sane and, realizing their guilt, are ready to compensate for the damage. If the conversation did not work out, then it is better to write a written claim and send it by mail. It is unlikely that your opponent receiving it the next day will bring you a lot of money, but you will have written confirmation for the court, from the fact that you tried to resolve the issue out of court.

A sample claim can be found online and free download... It is not at all necessary for someone to pay for the so-called vocational training of this document... In the text of the letter, it is necessary to indicate briefly the circumstances of the incident; the amount calculated by the appraiser during an independent examination of damage after the flooding of the apartment; the price at which you agree to concede, for the sake of a peaceful resolution of the issue; and the terms that you give the respondent for reflection.

All this is sent with a notification by mail. A copy of the claim is provided by you to the court as evidence.

Independent expert report on damage assessment. Sample.

This is a multi-page document (includes about 40 sheets) answering the question of how much the perpetrator owes the victim and why. The judicial assessment consists of several large sections: general data about the object, analysis of the market for building materials and services, construction estimates for the renovation of an apartment, photographs of the damage to the premises made by the appraiser, copies of documents for the object under study, permits (diplomas, insurance licenses, certificate, etc.). ).

The final calculation of the cost of damage after the gulf for the convenience of the customer is contained in information letter... This amount is the cost of the claim, which will subsequently be indicated in the statement of claim. The state duty for going to court will be calculated from her.

When you do not need to notify the respondent

When the apartment is flooded, the management company (DEZ, HOA) draws up an act confirming the very fact of this incident. In addition to the place, time, reason and other circumstances of the flooding of the apartment, the act also lists the damage to the premises. In the event that the damage specified in this act fully corresponds to the actual damage, then the culprit may not be invited to assess the damage from the gulf. Do not send him a telegram and do not give a notification in front of witnesses.

Why? And because all the damage described by the appraiser at the inspection will exactly overlap with what the representative of the third-party organization indicated. Thus, the claims of the defendant in court regarding the bias of the assessment will be dispelled.

Do you go out to appreciate the bay of an apartment in the far suburbs?

The main specificity of litigation in separate cities is their isolation. The clannishness in the city management system gave rise to the phrase: a hand washes a hand. So, for example, doing an examination of damage to an apartment from the actions of housing and communal services in some local appraisal company, you can run into low prices, since these appraisers are tied with lawyers from the local DEZ.

Therefore, trips to the distant suburbs and those adjacent to the Moscow region are very frequent for our experts. Yes, you will have to go to Moscow for a ready-made examination. But the principle of independent appraisal will be respected, as well as all the realities of market prices will be taken into account. In addition, the constant flow of customers allows us to make an assessment of damage after the gulf much cheaper than specialists in remote settlements.

Is the information helpful?

Save it to your wall.

In cases of application material damage apartment owners by neighbors, it is necessary to conduct a professional examination to assess the cost of repairs. The ZhilTekhExpertiza company provides clients with services for an independent examination of an apartment after the bay in Moscow to identify violations and defects that have arisen for one reason or another.

Why is a forensic examination of an apartment carried out?

To compensate for the damage caused in the amount of the cost of materials and work, you must go to court. This action includes several mandatory requirements that are fulfilled during the consideration of the case.

The litigation bases its decision on the findings of the research carried out. In most cases, the court carries out its own expertise, however, it can accept the opinion of independent experts.

Prices for the examination of an apartment after the bay

What damage is required for a court assessment?

Depending on the situation and the degree of its harm, the consequences can affect various structural elements.

The most common type of damage is apartment flooding. It spoils almost all elements of the structure, electrical wiring, plumbing and ventilation. Therefore, the following types of damage are assessed:

  1. The price of the renovation is based on the market value of materials and interior restoration services.
  2. In the event of irreparable consequences, the costs of a new living space are estimated, corresponding to the cost of the previous one and the budget for the repair work.
  3. Additionally, the functionality of electrical equipment and other devices in the apartment is checked.

What documents do I need to submit for the assessment?

To conduct an examination, the owner of the apartment will need to submit the following documents to the specialists of ZhilTekhExpertiza:

  1. Damage inspection report received from the organization operating the building.
  2. Documents certifying the ownership of the apartment.
  3. BTI documents for the premises. They are more needed for judicial trial, however, will not be superfluous for experts.
  4. Photos confirming the existence of damage.
  5. Invoices and checks confirming the actual value of the property.

The rest of the set of documents is presented at the request of the court. It is better to prepare all available papers in advance.

What to do in case of flooding?

First of all, after the apartment is flooded, it is necessary to call the representatives of the organization operating the building. The cost of damage depends on the speed of your response. Employees will determine the cause of the gulf and draw up an act confirming the damage.

It should be noted that in the event of the operating organization's fault, the act may not be drawn up. This is a legal violation, so you can safely demand a document or a written refusal to draw it up. The original is obtained at the company's office. After receiving all the certified papers, experts are called and an application is drawn up to the court.

Stages of forensic examination of an apartment and drawing up an opinion

The whole process of examination of an apartment for the court is divided into five main stages, during which the customer is provided with detailed information about all violations, defects and damage to property:

  1. The client submits the documentation to the company and the apartment is inspected.
  2. Technical expertise of premises.
  3. Analytical research based on the data obtained.
  4. Comparison of the market value of materials and services for the restoration of premises.
  5. Drawing up a report and conclusion.

Employees of the ZhilTekhExpertiza company have extensive experience in the field of forensic examinations. We carry out a detailed examination of the premises, providing complete information about the damage caused. She will help to achieve maximum payments in court proceedings.

Forensic examination apartments
Forensic examination of the quality of apartment renovation
Work, apartment, execute, expert, cost, examination, survey, determine, in fact, measuring

Construction survey object: apartment renovation

Expertise address: Moscow

The purpose of the examination: according to the results of the expert and diagnostic examination of the interior decoration of the apartment, the experts were asked the following questions for permission:

  1. Determine the volume and cost of actually performed work in the apartment, under the contract for the performance of contract work, based on the prices agreed by the parties in the application for repair and construction work.
  2. Determine the cost of substandard work performed in the apartment, under a contract for the performance of contract work, based on the prices agreed by the parties in the application for repair and construction work.

The object of the study was an apartment located in a five-story residential building.

The expert examination was carried out in a natural way based on the use of visual registration, measuring and non-destructive methods, with the subsequent comparison of the data obtained during the examination with the normative and technical documentation and case materials related to the production of expert examinations, as well as with the production of the necessary engineering calculations according to the results of instrumental measurements, in accordance with the current regulatory and technical documentation.

For the production of instrumental measurements, the expert used the following technological means, measuring tools and equipment:

  • digital camera "Canon Power Shot SX150 IS";
  • laser rangefinder leyca disto D5 No. 0498293;
  • steel measuring tape (GOST 7502-89);
  • level 2 meters (GOST 9416-83).

Conclusion on the forensic examination of the apartment

The expert determined the scope of actually performed work, which can be visually confirmed. The estimator calculated the cost of actually performed work, as well as the cost of substandard work provided by the expert.

: answer the questions posed in a federal judge's ruling district court of Moscow on September 22, 2017 on the appointment civil case No. 2-4999 / 2017 on the claim gr. X to gr. Y, gr. Z and gr. V on compensation for damage caused by the gulf of the apartment, forensic construction expertise:

  1. What are the premises in the apartment located at the address: Moscow, st. XXXXX, 28, apt. 15, were damaged as a result of the gulf that took place on 06/12/2017 ?;
  2. How long has it been renovated in the premises of the above-mentioned apartment affected by the gulf ?;
  3. What is the market cost of the refurbishment of apartment No. 15 located in the building No. 28 on XXXXX Street in Moscow after the gulf of 12.06.2017, taking into account the deterioration of the residential building and apartment?

Research part

Object of study- an individually defined object presented for the production of a forensic examination in a specific case. V this case- the object of research is the exploited premises of apartment No. 15 at the address: Moscow, st. XXXXX, 28.

During the expert examination, all premises of apartment No. 15, located at the address: Moscow, st. XXXXX, 28. Damage to the finishing coating was recorded as a result of the gulf that took place on June 12, 2017, in the following rooms: in the kitchen, toilet, corridor.

There are damages in the kitchen room: streaks and smudges from water on the ceiling surface, streaks from water and peeling of wallpaper on the surface of the walls, in the toilet room the paint coating of the wall in the sanitary cabinet is damaged, in the corridor there are streaks and streaks from water on the ceiling, streaks from water, etc. peeling of wallpaper on the walls, partial divergence of planks, darkening of the edges of parquet boards, fragmentary peeling of the top layer of parquet boards.

The cost of refurbishment is the cost of refurbishment to bring the finishing coat to technical condition preceding the bay.

In the process of inspection and research, the area of ​​structural elements (ceiling, walls, floor) was determined, defects from the effects of water in the rooms under study were recorded. When drawing up the conclusion, the expert identified the necessary measures to eliminate the consequences of the gulf.

The calculation of the amount of work for wallpapering, painting the ceiling was made over the entire surface, based on the fact that partial repair (removal of stains, partial painting) is not possible, because requirements of SP 71.13330.2011 updated edition of SNiP 3.04.01-87 "Insulation and finishing coatings" at the same time cannot be complied with. Since the area of ​​"defeat" of the floor covering from the parquet board exceeds a third of the area of ​​the corridor room, it is necessary to provide for its replacement, not repair.

*******************************************************************************************************************************************************

Answers to the questions posed in the ruling of the federal judge of the district court of Moscow dated September 22, 2017 on the appointment in the civil case No. 2-4999 / 17 under the claim of gr. X to gr. Y, gr. Z and gr. V on compensation for damage caused by the gulf of the apartment, forensic construction expertise:

Question number 1... What are the premises in the apartment located at: Moscow, st. XXXXX, 28, apt. 15, were damaged as a result of the gulf that took place on 06/12/2017?

Answer to question number 1: During the expert examination, all premises of apartment No. 15, located at the address: Moscow, st. XXXXX, 28, apt. 15. Damage to the finishing coating was recorded as a result of the gulf that took place on June 12, 2017, in the following premises: in the kitchen, toilet, corridor.

Question number 2. How long has it been renovated in the premises of the above-mentioned apartment affected by the gulf?

Answer to question number 2: According to the plaintiff gr. X, the last renovation was in 2005. No supporting documents. According to the condition of finishing coatings in apartment No. 15, located at the address: Moscow, st. XXXXX, 28, we can conclude that the repair was carried out more than 10 years ago.

Question number 3. What is the market cost of the refurbishment of apartment No. 15 located in the building No. 28 on XXXXX Street in Moscow after the gulf of 12.06.2017, taking into account the deterioration of the residential building and apartment?

Answer to question number 3: The market value of the refurbishment of apartment No. 15, located in the building No. 28 on XXXXX Street in Moscow after the gulf of 12.06.2017, taking into account the deterioration of a residential building and an apartment at the time of the expert study, is:

RUB 72,420.95

(Seventy two thousand four hundred twenty) rubles, 95 kopecks including VAT.